Gay Rights and Gay Bar Raids Before Stonewall
The 1960s and preceding decades were not welcoming times for gay, lesbian and transgender Americans. For instance, solicitation of same-sex relations was illegal in New York City.
For such reasons, gay and lesbian individuals flocked to gay bars and clubs, places of refuge where they could express themselves openly and socialize without worry. However, the New York State Liquor Authority penalized and shut down establishments that served alcohol to known or suspected gay patrons, arguing that their mere gathering was “disorderly.”
In 1966, three years before Stonewall, members of The Mattachine Society, an organization dedicated to gay rights, staged a “sip-in” where they openly declared their sexuality at New York City taverns, daring staff to turn them away and suing establishments who did. Their strategy worked. In 1967, a ruling from New York’s highest court affirmed gay individuals had the right to be served in bars.
Police raids were temporarily reduced after the lawsuit. But engaging in gay behavior in public—such as holding hands, kissing or dancing with someone of the same sex—was still illegal, so police harassment of gay bars continued. Many bars still operated without liquor licenses, in part because they were owned by the Mafia.
The Stonewall Inn
The Mafia saw profit in catering to shunned gay clientele, and by the mid-1960s, the Genovese crime family controlled most Greenwich Village gay bars. In 1966, they purchased Stonewall Inn (a “straight” bar and restaurant), cheaply renovated it and reopened it the next year as a gay bar.
Stonewall Inn was registered as a type of private “bottle bar,” which did not require a liquor license because patrons were supposed to bring their own liquor. Club attendees had to sign their names in a book upon entry to maintain the club’s false exclusivity. The Genovese family bribed New York’s Sixth Police Precinct to ignore the activities occurring within the club.
Without police interference, the crime family could cut costs how they saw fit: The club lacked a fire exit, running water behind the bar to wash glasses, clean toilets that didn’t routinely overflow and palatable drinks that weren’t watered down beyond recognition. What’s more, the Mafia reportedly blackmailed the club’s wealthier patrons who wanted to keep their sexuality a secret.
Nonetheless, Stonewall Inn quickly became an important Greenwich Village institution. It was large and relatively cheap to enter. It welcomed drag queens, who received a bitter reception at other gay bars and clubs. It was a nightly home for many runaways and homeless gay youths, who panhandled or shoplifted to afford the entry fee. And it was one of the few—if not the only—gay bar left that allowed dancing.
Raids were still a fact of life, but usually, corrupt cops would tip off Mafia-run bars before they occurred, allowing owners to stash any alcohol sold without a liquor license and hide other illegal activities. In fact, the New York Police Department had stormed Stonewall Inn just a few days before the riot-inducing raid.