Despite the freezing temperatures, the Bengals started hot. Recalling how both teams had been able to throw the football in the Ice Bowl, Gregg allowed his quarterback, Ken Anderson, an 11-year veteran with a pair of gimpy knees, to pass. The Bengals capped a 51-yard drive with a field goal to go up 3-0. After the Chargers fumbled the ensuing kickoff, Anderson threw a touchdown pass to tight end M.L. Harris, who caught the ball wearing the same brown, leather winter gloves he wore to the stadium.
On the sidelines, coffee dispensers joined Gatorade buckets. Players sat on 150,000 BTU propane-fueled benches that had been shipped from Philadelphia and huddled around more than a dozen kerosene-fueled heaters on the sidelines.
During timeouts, some referees grew a little too toasty at the heaters. “You smell something burning?” someone asked back judge Jim Poole. The referee looked at his smoldering shirt and realized it was him.
The frozen pigskin was as slippery as a greased pig and hard as a rock. After a paltry 27-yard boot, San Diego punter George Roberts returned to the sideline and muttered, “It’s like kicking a cinder block."
A 36-yard field goal attempt by Chargers kicker Rolf Benirschke didn't even reach the uprights. The stadium’s unforgiving artificial turf, which even on warm days provided the slim comfort of a throw rug on a concrete floor, was frozen solid so that players felt as if they were being tackled in a parking lot.
Like steam from a locomotive, the white plumes of breath that emanated from under players’ helmets as they ran down the field clouded their vision. “When you went to catch the ball,” Cincinnati wide receiver Cris Collinsworth told the media after the game, “your breath would come up and form a smokescreen in front of your face."
The Chargers responded to Cincinnati’s early lead with tight end Kellen Winslow’s 33-yard touchdown catch and scamper, but a 40-yard kickoff return set up a Bengals touchdown that gave Cincinnati a 17-7 lead. Two successive drives deep into Cincinnati territory ended with San Diego’s Hall of Fame quarterback Dan Fouts tossing interceptions, one of which occurred in the end zone.
Cincinnati Bengals Clinch First Super Bowl Berth
After a brief halftime thaw, the Chargers remained cold in the second half. After running back Chuck Muncie fumbled on the team’s opening drive, the Bengals took advantage of the turnover with a field goal.