The Forced Removal of Seneca Village: An African American Settlement
Some of the land acquired to create Central Park was already home to approximately 1,600 New Yorkers, including a predominantly Black settlement called Seneca Village. In 1825, a 25-year-old Black shoeshiner named Andrew Williams paid $120 for a parcel of land between West 82nd to West 89th Street. The area became a refuge for Black New Yorkers looking to escape the racial discrimination of unhealthy living conditions of Lower Manhattan.
By 1855, Seneca Village was home to 225 people, two-thirds of them Black. About half of Seneca Village’s Black residents owned their own home, which also gave them the right to vote. The government bought the land by the power of eminent domain and Seneca Village residents were forced to leave by 1857.
Olmsted Becomes Park Superintendent
In 1856, an initial plan for Central Park was drawn up by Egbert Viele, a cartographer hired as the first chief architect of the project. But Viele’s map of the park, while accurate and functional, wasn’t exactly inspiring. In 1857, the park commissioners announced a year-long competition to select a new and more innovative design for Central Park.
Before working on Central Park, Frederick Law Olmsted was not an architect or even a “landscape gardener” (as landscape architects were known in the 1850s). The son of a wealthy Connecticut merchant, Olmsted didn’t go to college (an eye condition kept him from enrolling at Yale), but he amassed a variety of life experiences that uniquely prepared him for designing public green spaces.
With his father’s support, Olmsted operated a farm on Staten Island, where he experimented with different drainage and soil improvement methods. In 1850, Olmstead went on a six-month “walking tour” of Europe and Great Britain. Always a lover of nature, Olmsted was inspired by the scenic countryside, but also impressive private gardens and public parks.
One park in particular—Birkenhead Park in Liverpool—left a deep impression on Olmsted. Not only did the urban park capture the rolling hills and shady woods of the English countryside, but it provided a democratic space where Liverpudlians of all walks of life could gather, breathe fresh air and commune with nature.
“The visit to Birkenhead Park was an ‘aha!’ moment for Olmsted,” says Petri. “He came back to the States and started writing.”
In 1852, Olmsted wrote Walks and Talks of an American Farmer in England and was hired by The New York Times to tour the American South and write about agriculture and slavery (Olmsted was an ardent abolitionist). Looking for his next gig, Olmsted learned in 1857 that the New York Parks Commission was hiring a superintendent of the Central Park project.
Olmsted had influential friends in New York’s political and literary circles—including the author Washington Irving—who helped push his name to the top of the list for Central Park superintendent. Even though he lacked direct experience with park-building, Olmsted was able to parlay his time spent farming, traveling and writing into a winning résumé.
“Olmsted got the job partly because of who he knew, but also because he could talk the talk,” says Brenwall. “He was very much a leader of men rather than an architect.”
Olmsted and Vaux Team Up on a Park Design
In 1857, Olmsted went to work on the Central Park project under the direction of Viele, who was still the chief architect. This was around the same time that the park commissioners announced the design contest to replace Viele’s lackluster plan with a new vision for Central Park. Olmsted might never have thrown his hat in the ring if not for a man named Calvert Vaux.
Vaux was a British architect who came to America to work with Andrew Jackson Downing, considered one of the first true landscape architects. One of Vaux and Downing’s high-profile commissions was to landscape the grounds of the White House and Smithsonian Institution in Washington, D.C.
In 1857, Vaux approached Olmsted about partnering on a submission to the Central Park design competition. As superintendent, Olmsted knew every crag and bog in the park. Plus, Vaux and Olmsted shared a belief in the democracy of green spaces, and a love of pastoral landscapes.
“They both agreed on a ‘nature first’ design philosophy,” says Brenwall. “Vaux is known for saying, ‘Nature first, second and third—architecture after a while.’”
Minutes before the submission deadline on March 31, 1858, Vaux and Olmsted handed in the 33rd and final entry to the Central Park design contest. Their design, called the “Greensward Plan,” not only included detailed architectural plans drawn up by Vaux, but “before and after”-style paintings of how the transformed landscape would look and feel.
Olmsted and Vaux wrote that Central Park “should present an aspect of spaciousness and tranquility, with variety and intricacy of arrangement, thereby affording the most agreeable contrast to the confinement, bustle, and monotonous street-division of the city.”
The Greensward Plan won the design contest, and Olmsted was subsequently hired to replace Viele as the chief architect of Central Park. Vaux, whom Brenwall called the “unsung hero” of Central Park, stayed on as Consulting Architect.